Customer Rating: 
Summary: Good on basics
Comment: I think putting emphasis on the visual basis of learning is a valuable instructional technique. As the author notes, watching good tennis players raises the level of our own game automatically. However, still photos can benefit from moving pictures. What we can take away from a visual approach to learning is not only a visual picture but a kinesthetic one--how it "feels." In this regard, I think that moving pictures would be an excellent addition to this book and, hopefully, a future edition will incorporate them.
As to the issue of "classical" Eastern forehand styles vs. the pro tour-dominated "Western" styles, with their heavy topspins, I can't fault this book like one of the other reviewers did for excluding the latter. Employing a heavy topspin style is an advanced technique and is beyond the focus of this book, which is obviously instructions for beginners. At the recreational and club level, I would hazard a guess that the majority of players do not use heavy topspin. Likewise, one of the best web-based instructional series--Brent Abel's WebTennis--is based on the "classical" style exclusively.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Good book but .....
Comment: This book is correct about learning by using visual images. For the last 8 years, I've been playing tennis using Yandell's images. But the only problem with this style is that it's not very good for competitive tennis. The forehand stroke that resulted from this book are more flat than topspin. The backhand stroke are also relatively flat. In competitive play, especially against modern players, these strokes are not suitable because of the tremendous topspin that they put on the ball. The strokes
photographed are not suitable to handle topspin shots.
The reason the top pros are not seen in the book is because they don't hit this way. This book is a good start for any beginner. After a few years of
playing using Yandell's photos, a beginner should have enough confidence to switch to modern tennis which is nothing but topspins.
I no longer hit the way this book suggests. But I still utilized the visual learning technique from the book. So get this book if you are a beginner. It will increase your tennis enjoyment.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Too old style tennis
Comment: I am very dissappointed after receiving this book.
This book teached only classical style(ex. only eastern
forehand grip)
If you want to play tennis just for fun, then buy this book.
BUT if you want to play well , forget this book, get lessons
from a modern tennis teaching pro.
Customer Rating:
Summary: The BEST way to master tennis strokes.
Comment: John Yandell has pioneered a new, and shockingly simple, way of first understanding how tennis shots are actually hit, and second how to teach this complex information in the most effective way possible to students. To answer the first question, I will quote John:
"Of the thousands of words coaches and teaching pros have used to describe tennis strokes in lessons, articles, videos, etc., no single element is more neglected and misunderstood than the role and position of the hitting arm. In fact, even the term 'hitting arm' is largely unfamiliar in the vast lexicon of tennis tips."
What John says is hard to believe, but as a life-long student and as a teacher for many years, I know what John says is right on the money. In tennis, no one has been able to identify, with certainty, the position and path of the wrist and forearm through the shot. It has all been guess work and impression. And this information, of course, is the key to hitting good shots! The reason John has been able to answer this question is through cutting-edge, high-speed photography, which shows us exactly how professional tennis shots are hit. The naked eye (and the reports and tips of pro players) are surprisingly incorrect and misguided perceptions of what really happens during a stroke. The strokes are just too fast to capture.
To answer the second question about teaching, John has discovered something that I have long suspected. People learn physical movements and skills by watching and observing real-life examples, and then repeating these examples. We do not learn physical movements by words and instructions. We learn these things visually. Furthermore, we do not break down the strokes into minute, piece by piece progressions. Instead the brain needs three "key" images -- the backswing, the point of contact, and the follow through--ingrained in its memory. Once these key images are remembered, it becomes very easy to turn them into full, uninterrupted strokes.
Like another reviewer here, I too turned a pretty average stroke (my forehand) into a powerful consistent weapon soon after using the visual system. And this was after years of following "tips" and "advice" of pros. The speed and level of improvement were just breathtaking for me.
In short, Yandell's ideas are pioneering ones in terms of learning, teaching, and understanding a complex sport like tennis. I urge you to check out his website, "tennisone.com" which has footage of pro strokes -- Agassi, Sampras, Venus Williams, etc in super, super slow motion. I agree with the reader that complained of the pictures in the book not being pictures of the pros. But John's website, with its library of super slow motion video of pro strokes (shot at 250 frames/second, whereas television replays are shot only at 30 frames/second) certainly rectifies this omission.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Cheaper and better than a lesson!
Comment: Having played competitive tennis for many years, having taught tennis, and having competed for many years in sanctioned USTA Open level events, this book is worth every penny. For many years my achilles heel was my forehand volley. No matter how many times I saw myself on video, how many volley lessons (at an average of $45 a lesson) I took, how much I competed in singles and doubles, how much tennis I saw, I could never hit a forehand volley with consistency, acuracy, and confidence. After visually seeing how to hit the volley and then practicing in front of a mirror as suggested in the book, I was able to hit a forehand volley RIGHT AWAY! With detailed visual cues to fall back on, I finally have a volley I can count on and keep. Amazing! This book is well worth having. Having taught tennis, I truly believe in the book's premise that we learn physical activities visually and not cognitively: our minds which can constantly criticize and judge our strokes can be our worst enemies on court (imagine trying to walk while TELLING yourself how to walk!); visual images are the best aids and this books provides great visuals.
