Customer Rating: 
Summary: A very good movie
Comment: A very good movie with a lot of "could be moments" and in which one can learn from.
Customer Rating: 
Summary: Atonement
Comment:
We recieved the dvd sooner than the date specified on the recept. It arived in great condition and we enjoyed the movie.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Moves the viewer through personal experiences of intense longing mixed with bitter misunderstanding.
Comment: Based upon the lies and misunderstanding of a young, unhappy, girl who seems to long for a dramatic life of her own, her older sister and her lover are betrayed. The young girl, completely ignorant of the intent and nature of her sister's relationship with a servant's son, vengefully lies, blaming the boy with molesting a young female family member. Set in the backdrop of WWII, the young lovers are separated when the boy is imprisoned for his alleged crime, being released only to fight in the war.
His love (Keira Knightly), working as a nurse, meets him only briefly during the war, but they re-declare their love and promise to meet. Promises, however, are broken by circumstance, and the lies and accusations of a young sister irrevocably change the lives of everyone.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Cinematically Great
Comment: This movie was placed high on my list of "I want to see that" simply because I like Keira Knightley's work. She adapts herself to her roles brilliantly.
When the movie opened in pre-WWII England and we are invited into the mansion that serves as the backdrop I thought we would be treated to another boring film about class distinction. Class distinction, yes; boring, maybe. The cinematography on this film is beautiful. However, seeing the same scene replayed from different viewpoints seemed to me a bit overdone. Perhaps that worked in the novel but on the screen it slowed down the story line.
There are various twists and turns to the story and if you haven't read the book you may become confused. Until the very end, that is. When the wonderful Vannessa Redgrave takes over as Briony near the end of the film, that is when everything we've seen begins to make sense. A wrapping up of the loose story lines that seemed to flounder once the romance has gone awry.
Revel if you will in this movie's wonderful acting by a superb cast, perfectly recreated period scenes, and grand cinematography. As with every epic movie there is a message or moral here: life isn't always fair.
I am giving this movie four stars because of the multiple views of scenes - a couple of people who watched this movie with me came away saying that it was confusing to them. I tend to agree although once I figured out what the director was doing it was easier to follow.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Excellent but not 5 of 5.
Comment: Overall a very good movie. I didn't give a full five count for a few reasons. At first I thought the director was a little indulgent in making the mansion too much of a character in the film. I got the point of wealth early on, but the theme may have been trodden down a bit with the endless walking through the hallways. Next, it's been a while since I was in Britain and I found myself turning on the English subtitles in order to understand the dialog. The actors, especially Keira Knightley who plays the older sister Cecelia, talked entirely too fast. I have been in the conversations of aristocrats while in England and their manner is slow and deliberate, not speedy. I guess we're to surmise her younger years and impetuousness precipitates her very rapid conversation. I literally timed one sentence that was two full lines long spouted in about half a second...quite irritating. So much so, I turned off the movie and watched at a later time when the house was quiet and I could put on my headphones to listen. Next, and no fault of the movie, the plot. Nothing rubs me wrong more than an unjustly convicted perpetrator. I have lost count of how many times I've watched movies and TV shows where we know the hero has been locked up for a crime he didn't do. And, finally, as in all British movies, the pace was a little tedious. Watching the special features tells me the director was conscious of this and cut a few scenes to keep the main story alive. So, I guess by British standards, it was fast.
Now the things I liked. Some excellent performances by Knightley (save for the rapid lips) and McAvoy. The intensity was real and not contrived. And I liked how the director kept the intensity and theme with the use of the typewriter sounds in synch with the music and movement of Briony. The cinematography was excellent, especially the 5-minute walk-through of the chaos on Dunkirk beach. This was real epic film making with very few special effects. The director used some 1000 local extras to make it happen. Finally, although I haven't read the book, I was led to believe that the screenplay was rewritten to follow the book as closely as possible. This materialized into several flashbacks which could have been confusing until it was nicely rapped up with Vanessa Redgrave as the 77-year old Briony explaining the meaning of the novel "she wrote."
This is not a feel good movie, so don't expect your typical chick flick happily ever after ending. DO expect to be drawn into the story through some convincing performances, a well written screenplay, and beautiful cinematography.
|
